BLV Sports Index Methodology

Methodology summary · Version 1.1 · Updated November 10, 2026

This page states the principles the BLV Sports Index is computed and governed by, so that every reading can be understood and held to a published standard. It is a summary. The complete computation specification, including calibration parameters, screening rules, estimator details and the constituent list, is proprietary to Black Label Vault and is not published.

The BLV Sports Index is a measurement. It is computed from completed sales of 500 specific graded cards. It is not an investment product, not a recommendation to buy or sell any card, and not a forecast. Nothing model-derived enters the level: not Heat, not seasonality, not the BLV Score. Those are context that may explain a move; they never compute one.

1. What the index is

The BLV Sports Index measures how the prices of 500 specific PSA-graded sports cards move. The composite is the BLV Sports Index. Each league has a sub-index, written “NFL · BLV Sports Index”. Each franchise has a team index, written “Dallas Cowboys index”. The index is never called “BLV Index”, “BLV 500” or “the 500”; the number 500 appears only as “500 constituents”.

2. The basket

Constituents500 cards, 125 per league: NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL.
One card per playerA player appears once in the whole index, in the league of the card chosen.
Card choiceUsually the player’s best-known rookie card, base version only, no parallels or variations, selected under written rules rather than by preference.
ErasFour eras by the year printed on the card, from before 1980 to today, with a target spread per league so no era dominates.
GradeOne PSA grade per card: the grade that trades most often for that card, so each constituent is priced where it actually changes hands.
LiquidityCards are chosen to have a record of completed sales at the chosen grade. Cards that stop trading are swap candidates under section 7.
EligibilityCards printed in a college, national-team or draft-night uniform are not eligible unless a league franchise held the player’s rights when the card was issued. A two-sport player appears once.

The constituent list is not published. It is maintained under the review process in section 8 and every change is recorded in the change log.

3. How a reading is made

Each day every constituent is priced from completed auction sales at its grade over the trailing 90 days, supplied by a licensed market-data provider. Asking prices are never used. Sales that are not a single card at the stated grade, and sales that sit far outside the card’s own trading range, are screened out. A constituent with too few qualifying sales keeps its prior price, is marked carried, and sits out of that day’s return.

The count of constituents priced from recent sales is printed next to every level (“150 of 500 priced on recent sales”). It is part of the reading, not a footnote.

4. Returns and levels

Equal weightEach priced card’s return counts the same regardless of its price, so a $100 card moves the index as much as a $50,000 card. The index measures how prices move, not what the basket is worth. A single card’s daily move is bounded so one sale cannot swing a reading.
League, team and era indicesThe same equal-weighted calculation over the cards in that league, team or era.
Composite, until November 16, 2026Each league carries one quarter of the composite regardless of how many of its cards priced that day.
Composite, from November 17, 2026Every contributing card counts the same across all four leagues, so weight follows evidence. On November 17 the composite history is restated once under this rule; league, team and era levels do not change.
BaseThe index was set to 100 on November 9, 2026.
ReadingOnce a day, from the prior day’s data. Readings are not real-time.

5. History and the back-test disclosure

Live history begins November 9, 2026. Levels shown before that date are back-calculated and hypothetical: they were built from the provider’s historical weekly price data with a different estimator from the daily computation, they exist for the composite and the four leagues only, and the basket was chosen with hindsight. They are drawn as a dashed line labelled “Back-calculated (hypothetical)” and must not be read as a return, a track record or historical performance.

Until December 9, 2026 the product shows the change since launch rather than a 30-day change, because a 30-day figure would compare a live level against a back-calculated one. Any year-to-date figure that spans the launch date carries the label “Incl. back-calculated”. Team and era history start at launch and have no back-calculated segment.

6. Team attribution

A card belongs to the team index of the franchise printed on it, permanently. A trade, a free-agent signing or retirement never moves a card between team indices, because the card is the security and the card does not change.

Player traded or signs elsewhereNo change. A display-only “now plays for” tag updates; it never enters any level.
RetirementNo change; the tag reads Retired.
Franchise renamed or relocatedRolls into the continuing franchise as the league’s official record states.
Franchise ended with no successorSits in a per-league Historical group.

Status: the rule is adopted and takes effect with the November 18, 2026 reading. Until then, team indices group by the team name printed on the card, so relocated and renamed franchises appear under their historical names in a “Historical franchises” group at the foot of each league. From November 18, a franchise that absorbs a historical name continues its own series with more cards; team indices under historical names stop; and the per-league Historical baskets start at 100. The drill-down shows the printed team on affected cards, and a display-only “now plays for” or “Retired” tag drawn from public league roster data and refreshed weekly. The tag is context for the reader; it never enters any level.

7. Changes to the basket

Quarterly reviewConstituents are reviewed quarterly. First scheduled review: February 2027. Changes take effect on the first daily reading after the announced effective date.
Cards that stop tradingA card that cannot be priced at consecutive quarterly checks is replaced in the same league and era slot, by a card of the same player where one exists.
Catalog changesIf a card leaves the licensed catalog, it is replaced at the next daily reading and logged within one day. This is the one change made without advance notice.
Grade changesOnly at a review, logged as a constituent change, because a new grade is a new security.
New playersAdded only at a review, after a seasoning period with a demonstrated record of completed sales.
Price shocksDeath, award, Hall of Fame or scandal: no membership change. The index measures the price move. A card is removed only when it cannot be priced or leaves the catalog.

8. Governance

Announcement

Rule changes and scheduled constituent changes are posted in the change log at least seven days before their effective date. Catalog changes and error corrections are logged within one day, with a restatement note when a level was affected.

Review process

The constituent list is maintained under written selection rules and checked by a separate validation step that scores the index on a fixed set of dimensions before and after every rebalance.

Conflict of interest

Black Label Vault’s founder owns sports cards personally, including cards that are or may become constituents. Constituents are chosen by the rules above, never to favor or avoid any holding, and no constituent change is made, announced or acted on outside the published review cycle. Holdings of staff do not affect any level.

Errors

A computation error that changed a published level is corrected, the affected readings are restated once, and the correction is logged with the dates affected.

Data rights and proprietary notice

Prices come from a licensed market-data provider that is not named on this page; see Market Data Providers. Black Label Vault stores only its own aggregate index levels and keeps no per-card price history. The BLV Sports Index, its name, its constituent list, its levels and its computation specification are proprietary to Black Label Vault. Index levels and constituent data may not be scraped, redistributed or used to construct a derivative index without written permission.

9. Change log

DateVersionChange
2026-11-091.0 launchFirst live reading at 100. Back-calculated history shown for the composite and the four leagues only, labelled hypothetical.
2026-11-101.0Methodology published. Product labels: change shown as “since launch” until December 9, 2026; “Incl. back-calculated” on year-to-date; dashed pre-launch segment; “team fund” renamed “team index”; teams with too few priced cards show no level.
2026-11-10, effective 2026-11-171.1Announced. Composite weighting moves from league-equal to constituent-equal: every contributing card counts the same across all four leagues. On November 17 the composite history is restated once under this rule. League, team and era levels do not change.
2026-11-10, effective 2026-11-181.2Announced. Team indices key on the continuing franchise instead of the team name printed on the card: renamed and relocated franchises roll into their current franchise as the league records it, and franchises that ended with no successor sit in a per-league Historical basket. Absorbing franchises continue their series with more cards; historical-name team indices stop; the Historical baskets start at 100 on November 18. League, era and composite levels do not change.
Announced1.3Effective date to be posted here at least seven days ahead. A bounded single-card move will carry its remainder into the next reading instead of discarding it.

Questions about the BLV Sports Index or this methodology? Contact us at hello@blacklabelvault.com. Black Label Vault is collection-tracking and valuation software. We do not take physical custody of cards.

Home · About · Terms of Service · Privacy Policy